50...FUTILITY : THE NAME OF THE GAME
Based on the book of Ecclesiastes (Eccl) [1]...Read more there
Based on the book of Ecclesiastes (Eccl) [1]...Read more there
Like its predecessor, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes
is part of what we call 'Wisdom literature'. Ecclesiastes
introduces us to Qoheleth, which means the 'President',
or 'Preacher'. We're meant to recognize him as Solomon,
but this is just a literary device to give credibility
to the text by linking it to Solomon's (earlier)
reputation for wisdom. In the form we know it the book
dates from after the Babylonian exile (post 538 BC.)
& maybe as late as the 3rd C. BC. 'Qoheleth' is not
a person's name. It simply means the person who calls
together the assembly, or presides over it, preaches to
it [2]. The material would probably have been
meant for & delivered at a coming together such as a
synagogue. Later, whatever else it has since become,
'church' means essentially a coming together of those
called to do so.
The main thrust of this rambling book is more or less the futility of anything & everything. Some translations still use the word 'vanity', spelled out as 'chasing the wind' (2:17) Whereas Job wrestles with the personal cost of bad things happening to people, good or bad, Eccl paints a pessimistic broader picture, asking, 'Is it all worthwhile? Is anything worthwhile?' A more positive note does also come through, though it's mainly limited to a kind of 'eat, drink for tomorrow we die' attitude (8:15). Passages such as 3:9+ & 7:13 are typical, & 9:10's warning (more or less, 'when you're dead you're dead!) is hardly encouraging. One important value of Eccl for us is to alert us to the undeveloped nature of Hebrew reflection on any after-life at this stage. Think of it as a stage in the development of Hebrew thought on an issue still unresolved in Jesus' day. The many thoughts expressed here are not always consistent, as they're seen through the eyes of 'Qoheleth' who has apparently incorporated many others' thoughts into his own along the way. Bear in mind, too, that though the book is unclear about God's role in things, whatever happens, God is, & God is there.
The main thrust of this rambling book is more or less the futility of anything & everything. Some translations still use the word 'vanity', spelled out as 'chasing the wind' (2:17) Whereas Job wrestles with the personal cost of bad things happening to people, good or bad, Eccl paints a pessimistic broader picture, asking, 'Is it all worthwhile? Is anything worthwhile?' A more positive note does also come through, though it's mainly limited to a kind of 'eat, drink for tomorrow we die' attitude (8:15). Passages such as 3:9+ & 7:13 are typical, & 9:10's warning (more or less, 'when you're dead you're dead!) is hardly encouraging. One important value of Eccl for us is to alert us to the undeveloped nature of Hebrew reflection on any after-life at this stage. Think of it as a stage in the development of Hebrew thought on an issue still unresolved in Jesus' day. The many thoughts expressed here are not always consistent, as they're seen through the eyes of 'Qoheleth' who has apparently incorporated many others' thoughts into his own along the way. Bear in mind, too, that though the book is unclear about God's role in things, whatever happens, God is, & God is there.
Ch.1 gives us a
foretaste of what's to come, a kind of over-view. Ch.2
introduces the theme of 'seeing things are so
unpredictable, why not enjoy yourself while you're alive
to do so!' Ch.3 begins with a stand-out poem
much quoted still in various settings [4]. You
can't escape this cycle so why not enjoy it while you
can! Ch.4 with its concern for the oppressed
& down-trodden reflects a glimmer
of what great Prophets have already said by now, but
doesn't urge any steps to improve their lot. Ch.5
also touches on injustice, but simply sees this, too,
as the way things are! So get on with your eating
& drinking while you can! Ch.6 is a morbid
reflection on the state of things, again without any
recipe for change - that would be futile, too,
wouldn't it?! Ch.7 almost turns a corner into
a more positive take on things, but rather spoils it
with its typically patriarchal put-down of women. Ch.8
praises Wisdom but even that ends us as 'eating &
drinking'! Ch.9 goes as far as saying love
& hate are both futile, recommends Wisdom again,
& laments that Wisdom coming from a 'poor' person
will not be valued - again without any pointers to
changing this state of affairs. Just get on with your
eating & drinking! The latter has by now become a
kind of response like that in a litany! Ch.10-12 are
basically a collection of proverbs like those in the
book that precedes this one. They are interesting but
make no discernible challenge to those who read them.
As if we didn't know it by now, 12:8 brings
this section to an end exactly as the book has started
with it's 'Sheer futility', Qoheleth says, 'everything
is futile'. NJB says of Ch.12:13
that it sums up the apparent aim of the book
quite positively: that we should stand in
awe of God & keep his commandments. That's not
unlike Jesus' 'two great commandments', is it?
Notes: [1] Not to be confused with Ecclesiasticus from the Apocrypha. [2] Our name for the book, Ecclesiastes comes from its Greek name that also gives us our 'ecclesiastic' & similar. [3] cf. IS 22:13, & 1COR:15:32, though both have a more positive context. [4] In the sixties Australian folk group The Seekers released a very successful version of this as 'Turn, Turn, Turn..'
Q...As we go through 'seasons of life' do we have strategies in place for ourselves in our seasons & to share with others in theirs?